You hired a nanny three months ago, paid her every Friday in cash, and just Googled "do I have to pay taxes on my nanny" at 11pm. Welcome to the club. Yes, you almost certainly do. If you paid a household employee $2,700 or more in 2026, federal law requires you to withhold FICA taxes and file Schedule H with your personal tax return. The good news: the right household employee tax software makes this manageable even if you've never run payroll before.
- If you paid a household employee $2,700+ in 2026, you're legally a household employer and owe FICA taxes.
- Dedicated software handles Schedule H, W-2 generation, and state filings — tasks standard payroll tools often skip.
- Full-service options run $50–$100/month; DIY tools cost far less and work fine for straightforward situations.
- The IRS can reclassify your "contractor" nanny as an employee retroactively — penalties included.
What Is Household Employee Tax Software (And Do You Need It)?
A household employer is someone who hires a worker to perform services in or around their home. That includes nannies, housekeepers, caregivers, gardeners, and private tutors. If you control what the worker does and how they do it, they're almost certainly your employee — not a contractor.
The nanny tax threshold for 2026 is $2,700 per employee, per year (IRS Publication 926). Cross that line and you must withhold the employee's share of Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%), pay the matching employer share yourself, and report everything on Schedule H — a form that attaches directly to your personal Form 1040. Standard small business payroll software rarely touches Schedule H. That's the gap household employee tax software fills.
What Good Household Payroll Software Must Actually Do
Not every payroll tool qualifies. Here's the feature checklist that matters for household employers specifically:
| Feature | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Schedule H preparation | Filed with your personal Form 1040 — most business tools skip this entirely |
| W-2 generation | Required for your employee by January 31 — late filing triggers IRS penalties |
| FICA withholding calculator | Splits Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%) correctly for both parties |
| State unemployment (FUTA/SUTA) support | State rules vary widely — some states require quarterly filings |
| Direct deposit | Saves time every pay period and creates a paper trail |
| Year-round support | Tax law changes mid-year — you need someone available when it happens |
Top Software Options for Household Employers in 2026
Here's an honest look at the four options you're most likely to encounter:
1. GTM Payroll Services
2. HomePay by Care.com
3. SurePayroll
4. PayHRoll
How to Get Started Without Overpaying
Take Lisa, a marketing director in Austin (a composite of clients we hear from regularly) — she spent two years paying her housekeeper off-the-books before an accountant flagged it during a routine review. The back taxes, penalties, and interest added up to more than a full year of proper payroll service would have cost. Don't be Lisa.
Here's what works for most first-time household employers:
-
1
Confirm employee status. Use the IRS behavioral and financial control tests. If you set the schedule and provide tools, they're a W-2 employee — not a 1099 contractor.
-
2
Set a pay schedule. Weekly or bi-weekly both work. Pick one and stay consistent — it protects you legally and keeps your records clean.
-
3
Calculate FICA correctly. Withhold 6.2% Social Security + 1.45% Medicare from the employee's gross pay. Then match it dollar-for-dollar yourself. That's your total FICA obligation each pay period.
-
4
Choose your tool based on budget. Full-service platforms (GTM, HomePay) run roughly $50–$100/month and handle everything. DIY tools like PayHRoll handle pay stubs and records at a fraction of that cost — good if you're comfortable filing Schedule H yourself or using a CPA at year-end.
-
5
File Schedule H with your Form 1040. Due April 15 each year. This is where you reconcile all the taxes withheld throughout the year. If you paid quarterly estimated taxes to cover it, you'll just confirm the totals here.
"The biggest mistake household employers make is treating their nanny as a contractor. The IRS almost always reclassifies them as employees — and when they do, the back taxes, interest, and penalties land on you."
Household employee tax software isn't overkill — it's the difference between a $50/month subscription and a surprise IRS bill. If you paid your nanny, housekeeper, or caregiver $2,700 or more this year, you're a household employer. Treat it that way, pick a tool that handles Schedule H, and file on time. The paperwork is manageable once you stop avoiding it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need special tax software just for a household employee?
Not always — but standard small business payroll tools often miss Schedule H, which is how household employers report taxes on their personal Form 1040. Software built specifically for household payroll handles this automatically, so you're not patching together two different systems at year-end.
What is the nanny tax threshold for 2026?
For 2026, if you pay a household employee $2,700 or more during the year, you're required to withhold and pay FICA taxes and file Schedule H alongside your personal return, due April 15, 2027. See our 2026 nanny tax threshold guide for a full breakdown by state.
Can I use QuickBooks or Gusto for a nanny or housekeeper?
Gusto supports household employees with Schedule H preparation, making it a reasonable option. QuickBooks does not natively generate Schedule H, which makes it a poor fit unless you're handling that filing manually with a CPA. Always confirm "household employer support" is explicitly listed before subscribing.
What happens if I've been paying my housekeeper cash without doing taxes?
Talk to a tax professional as soon as you can. The IRS allows voluntary correction and amended returns, and getting ahead of it is almost always less painful than being audited.
Do I have to pay state unemployment taxes too?
In most states, yes — if your household employee earns above the state threshold, you owe State Unemployment Tax (SUTA) on top of federal FUTA. Household-specific payroll software tracks those state-level obligations automatically so nothing slips through.
Getting your household payroll right isn't complicated. It's mostly just knowing which forms apply to you and using a tool that generates them. Start small, stay consistent, and don't let "I'll figure it out later" turn into an IRS notice.
Need clean pay stubs for your household employee? PayHRoll generates professional pay stubs in minutes — no subscription required.
Generate a Pay Stub Free →